The Crystal Ball - Super Bowl
February 1st, 2012Last week against the spread we were 2 – 0 straight up so there we are 7 – 3 straight up; against the spread we were 1 – 1 so there we are 6 – 4 which means that we will come in over average no matter what happens with the Super Bowl pick.
The Super Bowl is very much about hype and is the most over analyzed game of the year because it has to be. There are elements here on both sides that are advantageous one way or another but the balance is close in most areas. These are similar teams and the prospect for a good game is substantial, of course turnovers or a a couple of fortunate bounces could make a lot of difference.
The Super Bowl
New York at New England – The Patriots have the offense to score against anyone and most teams cannot keep up. This is based on the fact that the matchups are impossible to substitute for and few teams have a defense that can cope with their receivers. The passing game is versatile and precise; receivers can line up virtually anywhere. They are a bit one-dimensional; the running game is effective but underutilized.
The New England defense in the playoffs has looked considerably better than it did during the season, of course neither Denver nor Baltimore are exactly offensive juggernauts. Still their season statistics are somewhat misleading given that they were leading most games and willing to trade yardage for time off of the clock. Still this is not a good defense but they are not as bad as they have been portrayed either; unfortunately they have a limited pass rush and lack consistent deep coverage, a bad combination.
The Giants defense starts with their defensive line; they have a pass rush that is very effective and their lineup is deep allowing for a pass rush that keeps fresh due to their rotation. The tackles and linebackers are stout against the run and the secondary is competent. (This is easier when you know that your time in coverage will be limited by the pass rush.) They are as healthy as they have been at any time this season and a formidable weapon.
The New York offense is relatively healthy as well. The passing game is explosive an can make big plays, sometimes over looked is that this was the fourth most productive passing offense in the NFL. The running game has been inconsistent but having both backs healthy has improved things there somewhat. Overall they have offensive versatility that gives them flexibility.
Both offensive lines are solid with a slight edge to New England. New England has the better overall passing game; they have more weapons and better precision though the overall edge is not great; the edge in the running game at this point in the season goes slightly to New York. The Giants will not be able to exploit that advantage if behind and the Patriots defensive front is solid. New York has the better overall defense by a significant margin and the pass rush could be telling particularly if they should get a lead. The quarterbacks are much more evenly matched than many might believe but Brady has to be given the very slight edge based on experience.
While Patriot injury reports are not necessarily the most reliable indicators the injury to Gronkowski is potentially a significant blow to the Patriot intermediate passing game. A high ankle sprain could impact his speed and ability to make sharp cuts which would affect timing of routes. New England can ill-afford this particular injury if it does in fact impact his play.
When you have two weeks to prepare the coaching figures in; Belichick will certainly have something special planned. Scheming to slowdown the pass rush is certainly possible but defensively the Patriots have to field a consistent pass rush while maintain effective coverage. A tall order but perhaps possible; certainly there is extra motivation here. Any turnover advantage should be decisive and this should be a competitive game barring that. Still the talent advantage here is to New York if they can leverage it, Giants win 28 – 24.